Casino Ohio

I have always been a proponent of legalized gambling in Ohio. As I watched other states build casinos, I wondered how Ohio could let gambling revenue leave the state. Our budget is in shambles. Our schools are in need of funds. Our libraries are closing. The demographics of the state, especially in southern Ohio with its strong fundamentalist bent, tend to stack the deck against gambling initiatives. Initiative after initiative has gone down to defeat in Ohio.

They are now trying it once again. This time, the constitutional amendment would allow one casino each in Cincinnati, Columbus, Cleveland, and Toledo, with the state revenue being shared equally by all of Ohio’s counties. The Cincy casino will be located close to an area decimated by job losses, numbering in the tens of thousands over the past 5 years with the closing of Airborne Express and numerous auto manufacturing plants and its attendant suppliers in the Dayton area. The promise of 35,000 jobs is almost too good to pass up, notwithstanding the legitimacy of the job production claims. Ditto for Toledo.

The local Democratic Party chairman, Boss Betras, is opposed to the gambling initiative because a casino will not be located here. I am neutral as to that particular argument as I have concluded that appendage economic development around these casinos is negligible at best. Just drive down to Mountaineer and look at the hotels and restaurants and all the other businesses that have developed around it. What’s that? Oh ya!!! There aren’t any. The area is just as depressed now as it was when it Waterford Park years ago.

This time around, I am going to vote against Ohio’s gaming initiative; not because I oppose gambling, but because I think it will be an economic fiasco and not deliver near the economic benefit the proponents say it will. The time to do the casino thing was 10 years ago. That horse has left the barn.

Ohio is surrounded by casinos. In this area there is Mountaineer 40 minutes away in West Virginia. There are two casinos around Pittsburgh, the latest being the Rivers Casino in Pittsburgh by the stadiums, and the Meadows which is south of Pittsburgh with easy access to southeastern Ohio. From Ashtabula there is the Presque Isle Casino located in Erie, PA. From Toledo, there are three casinos in Detroit, and one in Windsor, Canada. There are numerous Indian casinos operating in Michigan. From Cincinnati there are several riverboat casinos located in Indiana within hour’s drive.

This leads me to the question as to just how many casinos a given area can support. Economic development would be a major plus if there were just a few games in town. But casinos are proliferating all over the place as states attempt to address budget problems with the promise of untold gambling riches. Certainly the Youngstown area is already served by three casinos within an hour’s drive. Is this part of the United States reaching the point of casino saturation and diminishing returns? Will the downside to gambling, which primarily affects the poorer segments of our society, outweigh the benefit received from generated taxes? There is no more of a regressive tax than a slot machine.

A 78 year old man came into my office recently. He was retired and a widower. He blew his entire retirement nest egg at Mountaineer, including all of the equity in his paid-off house through a reverse mortgage. That equaled over $160,000.00 over a 3 year period, and that is unconscionable. With casino saturation, how many more of these folks will there be? Ultimately, he will end up a burden to the state through Medicaid; and that is the big economic question. Will the returns of a casino in a saturated market generate enough state revenue to cover the burdens of state expenses that may result? I’m not so sure.

Think about it. Now, which way to the penny slots?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Strouss-Hirshberg; Things That Aren't There Anymore

Image
Youngstown was at the heart of the American industrial revolution in the mid 1800’s. During World War I, more steel came from Youngstown than anywhere else in the world. It’s no wonder, then, that the area was home of some of the best of everything, including department stores. Strouss-Hirshberg and McKelvey’s were the Macy’s and Gimbels of northeast Ohio, and offered to local residents the best of what money could buy. Strouss will always hold a special place in the heart of this area. It is hard to believe that there are twenty somethings today that haven't heard of it, or go “huh?” when you mention it. I tried doing some research on its history. Believe it or not, it is hard to find. As near as I could figure, the Strouss Hirshberg Company was originally known as D. Theobald and Company. Isaac Strouss clerked there, and eventually bought the store in 1875 with his new partner Bernard Hirshberg. The store was incorporated in 1906. The Readers Digest version of the life of the ...
Read more

Hope vs. Aspiration

Image
Don't forget to visit http://www.markknowsitall.com/ Hope: to have a wish to get or do something or for something to happen or be true. Aspiration : a desire or ambition to achieve something. As the 2008 presidential campaign heats up, Barack Obama is in full gear selling his vision for the future of America. He is for “hope” and “change.” …and oh yes, peace. He is also for “peace.” Aren’t we all? Obama, the oratorical wunderkind with the speech cadence of Martin Luther King, is doing a fine job of telling us what we should hope for, and how he is going to give it to us. He is a riveting individual and a spell binding speech giver. Hope is a good thing, right? Obama believes Americans are “hope” deficient. Americans “hope” for universal (read “government run”) health care, even though 85% of Americans have coverage, and 25% of those who do not aren't American citizens, and an additional 14% of those who don’t can afford it but simply choose not buy it, and a portion of the re...
Read more

Donald Sutherland's Pants

An adult coming of age movie entitled Garden State made the rounds last summer. A friend of mine told me it was worth watching, so I bought the DVD. If you are a fan of movies filled with generational angst, which I am, this movie fills the bill. But if you are easily offended by casual sex, drug use, spoiled brats, and generally slovenly behavior, stick with Casablanca . Let's face it. A movie in which one of the protagonists is a grave digger who steals the jewelry off dead bodies prior to their being put in the ground is not exactly The Brady Bunch . Included in the movie soundtrack is a song called In The Waiting Line . It is a "head" song. Translated: play it while getting stoned. The lyrics ask the musical question: "Do you believe in what you see?" And that, my friends, is the topic of this week's essay. Animal House is the quintessential college frat house slob movie. It was fairly raunchy when it was released in 1978. By today's standards, i...
Read more